The highly anticipated release of Superman: Immigrant’s Rise has ignited a fierce debate over the superhero’s immigrant origins, with comments from Fox News host Jesse Watters setting off a firestorm of controversy. The film, directed by James Gunn, portrays Superman’s journey as an allegory for the American immigrant story—an idea that has resonated with many fans but has also sparked outrage among some conservatives. Watters, known for his polarizing views, delivered a fiery critique on The Five that quickly went viral, adding fuel to the already heated national conversation on immigration and national identity.

Jesse Watters’ Controversial Remarks: A “Superwoke” Superman?

The controversy erupted on July 7, 2025, when Jesse Watters made a provocative comment during a segment on The Five about the upcoming Superman film. Discussing the film’s portrayal of the Man of Steel as an immigrant, Watters casually quipped, “If I wanted a daily dose of uninformed chaos, I’d turn on The View… oh wait, I already do.”

But the real uproar began when he followed up with a sarcastic remark about Superman’s immigrant roots, saying, “You know what it says on his cape? MS-13,” referencing the notorious gang that some associate with Latin American immigration.

The comment was meant as a jab at the film’s political messaging, which portrays Superman’s origins as a metaphor for immigration. However, the remark quickly turned into a lightning rod for controversy. Many took to social media to condemn Watters, accusing him of mocking immigrants and the character’s symbolism as a beacon of hope and inclusion.

“Jesse Watters just crossed the line,” one viewer tweeted. “Superman’s immigrant story is about hope and resilience, not fear and hate.”

The Backlash: Defending Superman’s Legacy

The response to Watters’ comment was swift and intense. On platforms like Twitter (X) and Instagram, fans and industry professionals came out in full force to defend Superman’s legacy as a symbol of hope and justice for immigrants.

Superman’s origins—an alien from the doomed planet Krypton who is raised by adoptive parents in Kansas—have long been understood as a reflection of the immigrant experience. Created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, both of Jewish immigrant descent, Superman has always been a character who embodies the ideals of resilience, justice, and inclusion. Many fans pointed out that the character’s immigrant story has been central to his identity since 1938.

One Twitter user responded, “Superman’s story has always been about overcoming adversity and finding a new home. His immigrant narrative is what makes him a symbol of hope for so many.”

James Gunn’s Vision: Superman as a Reflection of the American Dream

James Gunn, the director behind Superman: Immigrant’s Rise, has consistently framed the character’s immigrant origins as an allegory for the American Dream. In interviews, Gunn explained that he wanted to highlight Superman’s story as a representation of resilience and the belief that anyone, regardless of their origins, can make a difference in the world.

“Superman is the American immigrant story—someone who was sent here from a different world and embraced the best parts of humanity. He represents hope, kindness, and a deep commitment to justice,” Gunn said in a recent interview with The Times of London. “This isn’t just a film about a superhero—it’s about showing that no matter where you come from, you can be a force for good.”

While Gunn’s vision has been embraced by many, it has also sparked backlash from conservative circles, with figures like Jesse Watters accusing the film of pushing a “woke” agenda that politicizes the character’s story.

The Larger Debate: Immigration and National Identity

The conflict over Superman’s portrayal comes at a particularly charged time in American politics. Immigration has long been a divisive issue, with conservative factions advocating for stricter immigration policies and progressive groups pushing for more inclusive practices. As debates over national identity intensify, the portrayal of Superman as an immigrant hero has become a flashpoint in the larger cultural conversation about immigration.

Watters’ critique of the film highlights the growing tension between those who see immigration as a challenge to national identity and those who view it as an integral part of the American experience. Critics argue that the framing of Superman’s story as a political statement oversimplifies the complexity of the immigrant experience, while others believe that the film’s message of hope and inclusion is exactly what the country needs.

The Role of Celebrities in Political Discourse

The backlash to Watters’ comments also raises questions about the role of celebrities and media personalities in political discourse. While figures like James Gunn and the filmmakers behind Superman: Immigrant’s Rise have used their platform to advocate for a message of inclusivity, the controversy surrounding the film shows how deeply polarized the national conversation has become.

In an era where media, entertainment, and politics are so closely intertwined, the debate over Superman’s immigrant story reflects the larger battle for control over cultural narratives. While some view the film as a timely statement on the immigrant experience, others see it as another example of political correctness in the media.

The Enduring Legacy of Superman

For those defending Superman’s immigrant narrative, the conversation is clear: the character’s story has always been about the American Dream. It’s a story of resilience, finding belonging, and rising above adversity, qualities that resonate deeply with immigrants who have come to America in search of a better life.

As the debate continues, it is important to remember that Superman’s legacy is rooted in the values of hope, justice, and inclusion. Whether or not viewers agree with the political message of Gunn’s film, the character of Superman will always stand as a symbol of the possibility for a better future, no matter where you come from.

Conclusion: The Fight for Superman’s Legacy

The controversy surrounding Jesse Watters’ comments and Superman: Immigrant’s Rise has sparked a national conversation about immigration, identity, and the role of the media in shaping cultural narratives. As the film’s release approaches, the debate will only intensify.

In the end, Superman’s immigrant story remains a powerful symbol of hope and strength for millions, reminding us that no matter our origins, we all have the potential to contribute to a better world. Whether or not we agree on the political implications, one thing is clear: Superman’s story is here to stay, and it will continue to inspire generations to come.