Fox News is riding high after The Five pulled an incredible 3.851 million viewers in Q2 2025, making it the most-watched program on cable. But instead of quiet celebrations, the network is suddenly engulfed in rumors — and viewers can’t stop talking.

Multiple insider leaks suggest that Harold Ford Jr., the former Democratic Congressman and current rotating liberal co-host, is being considered to permanently replace Jessica Tarlov, who has been the show’s progressive lightning rod since 2022. What began as whispers exploded online, racking up over 1.7 million views on X within days, and fans are deeply split.

Some viewers are calling the move a “smart evolution for the show”, while others fear it could “break the chemistry that made The Five unstoppable.” Behind the scenes, however, insiders hint this may be just the opening move in a much bigger prime-time reshuffle — a strategic overhaul meant to solidify Fox’s dominance and reshape the network’s tone heading into 2026.

Why Ford? Why Now?

Industry chatter suggests Fox executives are intrigued by Ford’s calm, diplomatic style — a stark contrast to Tarlov’s fiery, confrontational approach. Reddit threads and viewer surveys praise Ford’s tone as “measured,” “respectful,” and ideal for tense political climates. Analysts say Fox may be testing whether a less combative liberal presence could expand the show’s reach without alienating its core audience.

Meanwhile, Tarlov’s tenure has been anything but quiet. Loved by some and loathed by others, she has become one of the most polarizing figures on the panel — especially after her recent viral clash with Jesse Watters, which insiders described as a “wrecking ball moment” behind the scenes.

Although The Five consistently pulls in nearly 20% Democratic viewers, the internal question seems to be whether that chunk is watching because of Tarlov… or in spite of her.

A Larger Strategy at Play?

The timing of these rumors is no coincidence. Fox is currently executing a $2 billion strategic push to outmaneuver legacy networks, led in part by Jeanine Pirro’s programming initiatives. Variety reports that the possible elevation of Ford could be part of a broader prime-time pivot — signaling a shift toward stability, polish, and a more mainstream tone.

With rival networks battling ratings declines, Fox senses opportunity. And tweaking The Five, its most valuable property, could set off a domino effect across the entire lineup.

Still — and this is key — Jessica Tarlov has not been removed, and Fox has made no official announcements. Snopes confirms that she remains a co-host, despite mounting speculation.

Fans Are Fired Up

Social media reaction has been explosive and divided:

“Ford brings class and clarity. Great move by Fox.”
vs.
“Jessica is the spark — pull her out and the show collapses.”

That mix of excitement and outrage has made the situation one of the most talked-about media storylines of the year.

Whether this is simply rumor-fuel… or the beginning of a sweeping prime-time rebrand… remains to be seen. But one thing is clear:

All eyes are on Fox News. All tension is on the table. And the next move could redefine cable’s most-watched show.

Will Harold Ford Jr. become The Five’s new liberal anchor?
Or will Jessica Tarlov’s high-voltage presence continue to shape the show’s identity?

For now, viewers — and the entire industry — can only wait for the next twist in Fox’s most compelling 2025 drama.