‘Dancing with the Stars’ Faces Major Shake-Up as Fans Call for Kym Johnson-Herjavec to Replace Carrie Ann Inaba

After weeks of growing backlash from viewers, Dancing with the Stars may be preparing for one of its biggest judging-table shake-ups in years. Fans of the long-running competition series have voiced frustration over judge Carrie Ann Inaba’s critiques, calling them “biased” and “inconsistent,” and many are demanding a change — with one familiar face emerging as the clear fan favorite to step in: former pro dancer Kym Johnson-Herjavec.

The conversation reignited after Kym returned to the ballroom this season as a guest judge. Within minutes of her debut, social media lit up with praise for her thoughtful feedback, calm demeanor, and genuine enthusiasm for the contestants. Fans immediately began comparing her style to Carrie Ann’s, with many saying Kym brought the balance of expertise and warmth the show has been missing.

“Kym has been a better judge in forty minutes than Carrie Ann has been in ten seasons,” one fan posted online, echoing a sentiment that quickly went viral. Others chimed in, calling her appearance “a breath of fresh air” and “what Dancing with the Stars needs right now.”

Behind the scenes, sources suggest that producers are aware of the fan reaction and are actively considering ways to respond. Discussions are reportedly underway about the possibility of expanding or adjusting the judging panel next season — and Kym’s name is at the top of the list.

Carrie Ann, who has been part of the show since its early days, has long divided audiences with her candid critiques and occasional emotional reactions. Some viewers appreciate her passion and eye for performance detail, while others believe her feedback often feels personal or inconsistent. The recent backlash appears to reflect a growing fatigue among fans who want the focus to return to constructive, dance-based evaluation.

Kym Johnson-Herjavec, by contrast, brings not only years of professional ballroom experience but also an intimate understanding of the show’s culture and spirit. A two-time DWTS champion and longtime fan favorite, she has built a reputation for encouragement and fairness — qualities many feel are needed now more than ever.

Her potential full-time return would also carry nostalgic appeal. Kym was one of the original pros who helped shape Dancing with the Stars into the phenomenon it became, and her comeback could help reenergize both the cast and the audience.

While no official announcements have been made, one thing is certain: change may be coming to the DWTS judges’ table. Whether it’s a total replacement, an expanded panel, or a rotating lineup, the producers seem to be listening closely to fan sentiment this time around.

For now, the ballroom is buzzing — not just from the dance floor, but from the growing speculation about who will be holding up the score paddles next season.